Just a snippet:
Inquisitor: If abortions had been legal, you might never have been born.
Me: So?
Inquisitor: Well, you would never have existed. Anti-abortion laws saved your life.
Me: Let's follow your line of reasoning and say I don't exist. If I don't exist then I can't care whether I might potentially exist or not because, well, I'm not here.
Inquisitor: That's not the point.
Me: How can I have an opinion on something if I don't exist?Let me finish this argument for him/her/it (I didn't bother to read its profile and I wouldn't want to insult it by using the wrong progressive-acceptable pronoun)
We prosecute murderers not because the person they murdered cares, they're dead after-all, we prosecute murder because killing someone is wrong. Abortion is wrong, especially in a society where so many options for responsible birth control exist. Heck, I'll even go so far as to accept early abortions, wrong as I feel they are. But to argue that abortion is OK because the babies killed don't exist now, well, that argument has a bit of a flaw...
Inquisitor: Bang!!!! Ok, you're dead now. You don't exist. I assume you don't care, right? What's that, you can't answer me because you don't exist? Argument won!
(and there's another flaw in the straw argument. The Inquisitor feels the baby did exist, he wouldn't state something so obviously flawed as "...you would never have existed".)
1 comment:
Abortion is just a pretty name for MURDER! The case of Roe versus Wade in the U.S.A. is in direct violation of the constitution that states the right to life and liberty, these babies are having there right violated even before they are born.
Every person who commits a crime or advocates said crime is guilty of a criminal offence, HANG THEM ALL.
Post a Comment